Hall of Fame
Miss New York USA
2021
Briana Siaca
2020
Andreia Gibau
Top 10 at Miss USA
2019
Florinda Kajtazi
Miss Photogenic at Miss USA
2018
Genesis Suero
2017
Hannah Lopa
Top 10 at Miss USA
2016
Serena Bucaj
2015
Thatiana Diaz
Top 15 at Miss USA
2014
Candace Kuykendall
2013
Joanne Nosuchinsky
2012
Johanna Sambucini
2011
Amber Collins
Top 16 at Miss USA
2010
Davina Reeves
2009
Tracey Chang
2008
Danielle Roundtree
2007
Gloria Almonte
2006
Adriana Diaz
2005
Meaghan Jarensky
Top 10
2004
Jaclyn Nesheiwat
2003
Nadia Behette
2002
Karla Cavalli
Semi-Finalist
2001
Lisa Pavlakis
2000
Carrie Tucker
Semi-Finalist
1999
Melissa Huggins
Succeeded Kimberly Pressler
1999
Kimberly Pressler
Miss USA
1998
Susan Wisdom
1997
Ramona Rueter
1996
Keelin Curnuck
1995
Shanna Moakler
Miss USA
1994
Jennifer Gareis
Finalist
1993
Wendy Mock
Semi-Finalist
1992
Christine Beachak
1991
Maureen Murray
Semi-Finalist
1990
Patricia Murphy
1989
Jennifer Fisher
1988
Linnea Mancini
1987
Constance McCullough
1986
Beth Laufer
1985
Lovey King
1984
Caroline Flury
1983
Jennifer Mikelinich
Semi-Finalist
1982
Annemarie Henderson
1981
Deborah Fountain
1980
Debra Sue Maurice
Semi-Finalist
1979
Mary Therese Friel
Miss USA
1978
Darlene Javits
1977
Debbie Martin
1976
Carol Doerr
1975
Sonja Anderson
1974
Barbara Cooper
1st Runner-Up
1973
Susan Carlson
1st Runner-Up
1972
Alberta Phillips
1st Runner-Up
1971
Barbara Lopez
1970
Christina Tefft
Semi-Finalist
1969
Rosemary Hradek
Semi-Finalist
1968
June West
Semi-Finalist
1967
Wendy Cox
1966
Nancy Self
Semi-Finalist
1965
Gloria Jon
Semi-Finalist
1964
Dorothy Langhans
Semi-Finalist
1963
Jeanne Quinn
Semi-Finalist
1962
Sherralyn Patecell
4th Runner-Up
1958
Virginia Fox
Semi-Finalist
1957
Sanita Pelkey
Semi-Finalist
1956
Kay Douglas
1955
Janet Kadlecik
Semi-Finalist
1954
Karin Hultman
1st Runner-Up
1953
Reta Knapp
Semi-Finalist
1952
Jackie Loughery
Miss USA