Hall of Fame
Miss New York Teen USA
2022
Mahdiya Chowdhury
2021
Geanna Koulouris
2020
Maya Dominguez
2019
Hailey Germano
2018
Saige Guerin
2017
Isabella Griffith
Top 15 at Miss Teen USA
2016
Natalia Terrero
2015
Geena Cardalena
Top 15 at Miss Teen USA
2014
Corrin Stellakis
2013
Nikki Orlando
Top 16 at Miss Teen USA
2012
Sabrina Mastrangelo
Top 16 at Miss Teen USA
2011
Lisa Drouillard
2010
Thatiana Diaz
Top 15
2009
Taylor Gildersleeve
2008
Sana Idnani
Miss Photogenic
2007
Tatiana Pallagi
2006
Candace Kuykendall
2005
Natascha Bessez
Semi-Finalist
2004
Catherine Muldoon
Top 10
2003
Adriana Diaz
2002
Marley Delduchetto
Semi-Finalist
2001
Gloria Almonte
1st Runner-Up
2000
Tina Casciani
1999
Morgan Maholick
Miss Congeniality
1998
Lindsay Fredette
1997
Jessica-Lynn Ferdinand
1996
Aiesha Hendrick
Semi-Finalist
1995
Tara Campbell
1994
Kimberly Pressler
1993
Sara Rae Gore
Top 6
1992
Amber Evans
Miss Congeniality
1991
Wendy Cooper
1990
Catherine Bliss
1989
Beth Savage
Semi-Finalist
1988
Jessica Collins
1st Runner-Up
1987
Michelle Kelenski
Semi-Finalist
1986
Claudia Liem
2nd Runner-Up
1985
Shelly Lounge
1984
Denise Scalez
1983
Ruth Zakarian
Miss Teen USA 1983